To the degree that outcomes are unknowable, the decision problems they pose are not well-defined. It follows that rationality—pure deductive rationality—is not well-defined either, for the simple reason that there cannot be a logical solution to a problem that is not logically
defined. It follows that in such situations deductive rationality is not just a bad assumption; it cannot exist. There might be intelligent behavior, there
might be sensible behavior, there might be farsighted behavior, but rigorously
speaking there cannot be deductively rational behavior. Therefore we cannot
assume it.
#